You are viewing mariness

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Feb. 5th, 2013

gottalovethepandas
Unbelievably out of it today -- so out of it that although I made coffee and poured it into a mug, I forgot to drink it; no, really -- but I did want to point Little House fans to the news that Mary Ingalls did not go blind from scarlet fever after all.

From a writing point of view, I'm fascinated by the suggestion that Laura Ingalls Wilder, Rose Wilder Lane, and the New York book editors all agreed that "vague viral or bacterial brain infection that we don't exactly have a name for" would be too confusing, and that it was better for Mary to have the literary illness of scarlet fever instead.

Particularly interesting since in literature (not reality, before people leap up to correct me) both scarlet fever and tuberculosis tended to turn children into inspirational household angels, beloved by all, probably best exemplified by Beth of Little Women. Some of this, of course, doubtless reflected the reality of mourning for lost children and a tendency to idealize their memories; some of this may have been attempts to alleviate the anger and resentment that healthier children may have felt about the need to care for their sicker siblings.

In the case of the Little House books, Mary Ingalls is initially described as a well behaved little girl with three traits that drove her little sister nuts: Mary is bossy, superior and prissy. After Mary's illness and blindness, however, she becomes the angelic center of the household: always helpful, always good, never losing her temper, the sort of person that you would want to sacrifice everything for, which the poverty-strapped Ingalls family did, having their daughter Laura work for pay starting at 13 (in the books; 11 in real life) in part to raise the money to send the talented Mary off to college and perhaps train her for a career despite her blindness.

It's a heartwarming portrait, but I've always wondered how much nostalgia and anger shaped that portrait. This study raises those questions all over again.

Ok. Hopefully I'm alert enough to go get milk and other necessities.

Comments

( 4 comments — Leave a comment )
seawasp
Feb. 5th, 2013 05:02 pm (UTC)
Well, the Pioneer Girl project is working publishing the original autobiography so many questions may be answered when that's released.

IIRC "Scarlet Fever" was blamed for MANY things. Wasn't that what they said had caused Helen Keller to go deaf and blind?
mariness
Feb. 5th, 2013 05:47 pm (UTC)
If Wikipedia is accurate Helen Keller may have had scarlet fever or meningitis? That's just Wikipedia, though, so take it for what it's worth.

I am looking forward to the Pioneer Girl autobiography, although from various biographies we already know bits of what's in it, including the facts that Wilder often softened the depictions of poverty in her books, while also presenting the places where she lived as more primitive than they often were. As I noted in an earlier entry, it can be difficult to remember while reading the Little House books that they are set during the Industrial Revolution, not colonial times. De Smet had a roller skating rink and several other amenities that Wilder never mentions, for instance, in part, I think, because that would have brought up the fact that Wilder often couldn't afford these amenities, which in turn would have focused attention on her father's financial failures, which was against the heart warming depiction of the loving, warm hearted adventurous yet respected man she wanted to portray.

But I'm definitely reading the autobiography once it's released.
babs_sg1
Feb. 5th, 2013 11:07 pm (UTC)
That is very interesting. What is strange is that I thought I remembered reading in the book that Mary went blind from having measles. I didn't remember that it said scarlet fever. Maybe as a kid, I automatically substituted measles (a bad disease I was familiar with) for scarlet fever (a disease I knew nothing about).
mariness
Feb. 5th, 2013 11:35 pm (UTC)
:: nods :: I think measles actually can cause blindness in some cases (don't quote me on this!) if the measles isn't treated properly, so it's possible that you took that knowledge and applied it to the memory of the Little House books?
( 4 comments — Leave a comment )

Profile

gottalovethepandas
mariness
Mari Ness

Latest Month

May 2013
S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Tags

Powered by LiveJournal.com
Designed by Tiffany Chow